Trotskyism, Wikinomics and Google

The other day, I got accused of being a Trotskyist. If you’re not sure what that means, don’t feel bad; I had absolutely no idea myself.

The woman who used the T-word on me furnished this explanation: evidently, Trotsky claimed that the general populace doesn’t understand the levers that interconnect society and the economy.

I had just pointed out that a large portion of the people who want to stop global warming don’t realize how much their day-to-day lives would have to change. Don’t get me wrong—I want to stop global warming too. But I still drive a car, and go on overseas trips, and buy imported products, and I fully appreciate that all of those things are intricately linked to our fuel consumption.

Right now I’m about 80% through reading Wikinomics, a study of mass collaboration. The book is driving home for me how absolutely massive the uphill battle is for companies looking to unseat Google, or Amazon, or any other organization that has understood and leveraged the collaborative model.

In my most recent piece for Search Insider, I wrote about the powerful force of habit that keeps me using Google for search, and touched on the fact that a tweak in features is nowhere near enough to make me change search engines.

Essentially, I don’t have a lot of pain when it comes to search, and minor features improvements just aren’t enough to motivate me to switch.

The Trotskyism issue, though, is much bigger. Google is not just Google. Google is every other company, website, blog and mashup that has built a business model on the back of the search giant. All of these entities have a vested interest in Big G’s continued success.

Companies that have Google as competition can’t win just by being better at search; they would also have to convince an entire population of individually crafted satellite businesses to switch to a new model.

The Internet is an ecosystem. Companies looking to succeed in this space have to understand more than just the competition; they have to understand how all of the organizations surrounding them interrelate and interdepend.

Do you see other examples of web-based ecosystems around you? What are they? What do they mean for companies and competition? And what do you think of businesses built around this sort of model?

4 Responses to “Trotskyism, Wikinomics and Google”

  1. My Ghillie » Trotskyism, Wikinomics and Google Says:

    […] Check it out! While looking through the blogosphere we stumbled on an interesting post today.Here’s a quick excerptTrotskyism, Wikinomics and Google October 19th, 2007 The other day, … Google, or Amazon, or any other organization that has understood and leveraged the collaborative model … me using Google for search, and touched on the fact that a tweak in features is nowhere near enough […]

  2. Raf Says:

    Nice post Kaila!

    I;m sure Trotsky would be very interested in the development of the web and gargantuan businesses like Google. For him there was only Permanent Revolution, a never ending process of growth, feedback, destruction and re-growth. Although he saw Socialism as a stage higher than capitalism he also realized that it wouldn’t end there (perhaps he was an integralist after all). As he said in his book “The Permanent Revolution”,

    “To aim at building a nationally isolated socialist society means, in spite of all passing successes, to pull the productive forces backward even as compared with capitalism”.

    In other words he was all for globalization and continued development. Open source collaboration would have appealed very much to how he saw the world: Connected.

    Isolation doesn’t work and we’re all in this together :-)

  3. Kaila Colbin Says:

    Wow, Raf! I’m looking forward to our next conversation so I can learn some more about this stuff. After I heard it, I looked up ‘Trotskyism’; I can’t say that I understood it very well.

    I do understand, however, your last statements: we’re all connected; isolation doesn’t work; we’re all in this together. Right on, Trotsky! :-)

  4. blog.vortexdna.com » Blog Archive » Trotskyism update: Firefox backed by Google Says:

    […] a few days ago when I wrote about the ecosystem that surrounds Google? I said that Google isn’t just Google; it’s every other company, website, blog and […]

Leave a Reply

*
To prove you're a person (not a spam script), type the security word shown in the picture. Click on the picture to hear an audio file of the word.
Click to hear an audio file of the anti-spam word